|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Turing Test Added to Comments2007-06-11Turing Test Added to CommentsBlog spam is almost as rampant as email spam, and it’s starting to fester among the comments on our blog. To keep it from getting out of hand, I’m implementing a couple of changes that should slow down (if not stop) these common blog spamming techniques. The first change is that TrackBacks are now turned off. This isn’t a huge deal, because they hadn’t been on since the blog’s beginning until recently. I turned them on last week, because I thought they might be useful. I see now that they’re mostly useful for spam, so now they’re back off. The second, and more important change, is the addition of a Turing test when adding comments. Instead of using a captcha to verify that whatever entering a comment is a sentient being, the Turing test uses a natural language question. This should keep the automated scripts that post blog spam from doing so, because they can’t answer the question unless they’re designed to know the answer specifically for our blog comment form. And because that defeats the purpose of having an automated method of blog spamming, it should do the trick. The question isn’t hard. In fact, because we’re just out to spoil the automated non-friendlies, we can even talk about it here. We’re often asked, "What do the G and W of GW Micro stand for?" G stands for Geoffray, Doug’s last name, and W stands for Weirich, Dan’s last name. They both share the company, and therefore both share the name. Now, when you post a comment, one of the form items to fill out is a question asking what the G in our name stands for. Fill it out correctly (i.e. spelled right, with the first letter capitalized), and your comment will go through. Fill it out wrong, and your comment will not get posted. Although this adds one more step (albeit rather small) to posting comments, it will keep the entries on track, and spamless. Oh, and if you’re a registered user, the question edit box will be filled in automatically. Comments, Pingbacks:
Good idea! Some people might whine if they didn't read this post but they need to get over it!!!
Marvin, you bring up a valid point, and my goal isn't to turn away good comments. So I've added a link below the question's edit box that says, "Why am I being asked this question?" It links directly to this post, which should clear up any confusion. Thanks for bringing that up.
Comment from: Sara [Visitor]
I just want to say his is great, thanks for the combination of accessibility and getting rid of spammers. smile
Sara from Canada, hoping the system thinks she is a real person, big grin
This is a great safeguard, Aaron. Now let's see how this safeguard works.
I think this blog is a wonderful addition to GW Micro's many methods of communicating with its customers. Thanks for taking the time to make it worth reading and commenting on.
Comment from: Jared Rimer [Visitor]
How can I implement some type of system like this on my blog?
There are good sources about it on the following link
http://www.whatusearch.net/consumers/
Comment from: Marky [Visitor]
It links directly to this post, which should clear up any confusion, thanks for the combination of accessibility and getting rid of spammers, I think this blog is wonderful
Comment from: Iama Spammer [Visitor]
Thought I better test out your new anti-spam system to see if it works well.
Comment from: Steve [Visitor] · http://www.mynextpc.co.uk
Kinda a hard test, I didn't know until I read the article what the G in GW micro stood for. Personally using number adding ones, through I do like the idea.
i.e. The quick brown fox jumped over the lazy what?
Comment from: Steve22 [Visitor]
Yeah true, Wonderful addition to GW Micro's many methods of communicating with its customers
Comment from: ars [Visitor] · http://www.ziza.ru/
And what about own well formed capture algorytm?Then verify question can`t save from half-automatical spam.
Comment from: Jake [Visitor]
This certainly beats trying to solve a visual-only or even an audio CAPTCHA. If all sites used this kind of thing for their CAPTCHA then I think we'd be well on our way towards achieving maximum accessibility for all.
Leave a comment:
|
Archive
SearchMisc |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
© GW Micro, Inc. All Rights Reserved. GW Micro, Inc. 725 Airport North Office Park Fort Wayne, IN 46825Ph: 260-489-3671 Fax: 260-489-2608 www.gwmicro.com sales@gwmicro.com support@gwmicro.comHours: M-F, 8a-5p, EST |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||